Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Taking Down America

At the moment, within the United States, it is the political right that is the loudest purveyors of a coming doom and gloom.  However, there are actually quite a few voices on the left.  Coming from TomDispatch: Taking Down America

A soft landing for America 40 years from now?  Don’t bet on it.  The demise of the United States as the global superpower could come far more quickly than anyone imagines.  If Washington is dreaming of 2040 or 2050 as the end of the American Century, a more realistic assessment of domestic and global trends suggests that in 2025, just 15 years from now, it could all be over except for the shouting.
Despite the aura of omnipotence most empires project, a look at their history should remind us that they are fragile organisms. So delicate is their ecology of power that, when things start to go truly bad, empires regularly unravel with unholy speed: just a year for Portugal, two years for the Soviet Union, eight years for France, 11 years for the Ottomans, 17 years for Great Britain, and, in all likelihood, 22 years for the United States, counting from the crucial year 2003.
Alfred W. McCoy offers for scenerios:
  • Economic Decline: Scenario 2020
  • Oil Shock: Scenario 2025
  • Military Misadventure: Scenario 2014
  • World War III: Scenario 2025
Some of these are, within prepper parlance, slow and some of them are fast collapse.  None of the scenarios seem to offer much guidance other than an idea that a limited retreat now is better than a cataclysmic one later.
I do not have any huge problems with the scenarios.  The idea that our problems started with Bush W. is in my opinion more polemic than substantive.  Also, the assumption that the United States is the only large country on a collision course with disaster strikes me as having a rather blinkered view of reality.  How China is supposed to maintain its growth with a population 4 times larger than the United States, and not suffer major problems from an oil disruption is also a bit mysterious.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Chinese missles non-news

By way of warning on taking press reports too much at face value:

The Financial Times- Asia had a story on a new anti-ship ballistic missile system.  The system would presumably be big, and fast.

Chinese missile shifts power in Pacific by Kathrin Hille in Beijing which ended with the following:
China also needs to deploy more satellites to ensure seamless tracking of a moving target at sea. But defence experts warn that the weapon would immediately be a threat to US carriers because China could make up for a lack in accuracy by launching larger numbers of missiles [emphasis added].
Well no actually, the ocean is large, very large, oversized Mens-Only Outlet XXX-large.
As noted here, in broken English, ballistic missiles are fast, but have limited in-flight targeting.  A very fast Mach 10 missile will reach 2,000km straight-line in just 11 minutes.  Taking into account the (actual)  parabolic trajectory of the missle, would lead to an in-flight time of 25 minutes to reach the 4,000km range.  In that time frame the 55 km/hr carrier task force will move 23 kilometers.  This is probably not not fast enough to make the missile lose sight of the carrier.  As the article (I think) notes in a cluster of ten missiles, eight of them would still be on target.

But that requires you know the exact starting of point, of the carrier.   As you become less certain, the distance your missiles need to cover does not double, but squares.  So if you only knew where the carrier was (via sonar, rpv scouting, etc) within 30 miles (pretty good actually) your carrier coverage area would go from 5,215 km sq, to 29,825 km sq (23 pi r sq versus 55 pi r sq).  So maybe only two of the missiles at the edge of the pattern catch the carrier, and that is number the task force might be able to shoot down.

Aircraft carriers are very vulnerable to both modern underwater threats, and missiles, but there is still no magic bullet to knocking them out.  The Chinese can certainly make operations off their coast very dangerous, but it won't be free.  They will either have to make these land based missiles mobile and hope they can get them close to where they are needed, or they will need a lot of them to be sure all areas are covered.

If they are not able to improve their ship detection systems to where they can be reliably used, they would be better off only making a light investment in the technology and use it in combination with the other systems they have in place.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Cannibalism 3½ Lessons to be Learned

Since we had so much fun in the Ukraine, lesson ran into three parts.

So what bullet points can we take from this:
  • Cannibalism cannot be counted on as a long term survival strategy.  If everyone does it, you run out of people.  If nobody does it but you, you are a pariah; just ask Jeffrey Dahmer.
  • Cannibalism shows up in many long term famine or starvation situations.  It may not be a good strategy, but it will occur.
  • A majority of people would rather starve than be cannibals.  Even in situations of mass starvation, the cannibals generally stayed low key initially.  As time went on the starving people became a little less shocked by it.  It does not appear to ever have been used on people who were well off and able to defend themselves.  Rampaging hordes of cannibals are somewhat unlikely.
  • In modern times man-made causes of famine are very common.  In some cases the government went so far as to confiscate food from starving people.  Being too public about the possession of food, or simply to fat and happy is likely to lead to confiscation.
  • Linked to the above.  Political circumstances often cause the famines to be directed against certain particular types of individuals or groups.  If you could be classified within one of these groups (racial minority, religious minority, etc) than various precautionary measures would be of particular importance.
  • Those without money or tradable resources (ie: the poor) will suffer most.
  • They can easily last two years.  The turbulence that surrounds some of these events, even when warfare is not involved, seems to necessitate an extended recovery time.
  • We will cover this in more detail later.  But the largest killer in most famines is not starvation, but the final  deadly horseman:  Death:  often referred to as Pestilence.

When the Lamb opened the fourth seal, I heard the voice of the fourth living creature say, "Come!" I looked and there before me was a pale horse! Its rider was named Death, and Hell was following close behind him. They were given power over a fourth of the earth to kill by sword, famine and plague, and by the wild beasts of the earth.
The Fourth Rider:  Death - often referred to as Pestilence


Sunday, January 2, 2011

Global Warming going into 2011

stunning year in climate science reveals that human civilization is on the precipice

This is just a link post.  I may go through certain portions of it in the future.  It is pretty thorough and pretty depressing.